About Me

Name: Bob Siegel
Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Blog Roll

 

The Truth About Israel and Palestine: Part One


 

We’ve all taken tests and quizzes in school. The true /false test was my favorite because it meant that even if I hadn’t studied, (which was often) I still had a fifty/fifty chance. Yes, indeed, those little true /false things saved my lazy, rebellious neck. To a lesser degree, I also enjoyed multiple choice because even though the odds were not quite as good as true/false, I at least had a one in five chance. As for fill in the blank? Um… Let’s not go there.

 

I also made an interesting observation about true/false tests. I discovered that most answers (for some reason) were true, even when they were written in a tricky way that suggested, false.

 

Well, today, I offer you a true/false test about the Middle East. It’s purpose: To challenge the conventional wisdom and naïve beliefs of the day and to correct the horrible historical revision going on, from the media, to the college campus, to the clever comments that come out of your friend’s mouths around the water cooler or at cocktail parties.  But since I am correcting “established facts,” allow me to offer you a little clue. This time, most of the statements will be false.

 

Before the test begins, I need to make an important introduction.

 

First of all, today’s article is the beginning of a series. You can find each subsequent chapter the very next day on Town Hall.

 

At the end of each essay, I will place a bibliography so that you can be aware of the extremely well- written and carefully documented books I am using as sources.

 

Interesting, how Jewish documentation is considered a tainted source while the words of Anti-Semites or sincere Gentiles who grew up hearing myths about the Jews are not viewed with suspicion.  How often do we hear that The Holocaust never happened?  To back up this “fact” it is pointed out that most books written about The Holocaust are written by Jews. This should not surprise us. Who will be more concerned about Hitler’s holocaust then the Jews?  Who will want to warn us about the possibility of another holocaust more than the Jews?  At the same time, I like to point out that one of the definitive non-fiction pieces about the Nazis, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, was written by a Gentile (Shriver), not to mention the films of concentration camps and German, government level documents. (The Nazis had an odd eccentricity. They carefully documented just exactly what they planned to do.)  Finally, the Nuremberg Trials, conducted by the United States and Great Britain, gave the world a generous and detailed record of actual Nazi confessions.

 

But try explaining any of this to the Historical Revisionist Society. And try explaining this to Iranian leader, Ahamadinnejad, who, with one side of his mouth, says The Holocaust never happened and with the other side says that actually, a holocaust might not be such a bad idea.

 

History tends to repeat itself. Just imagine if you could take a trip back through time to Germany in the 1930’s.  What would you say to people?  How would you attempt to warn them of what was about to happen?  And would they believe you?  Probably not, because what the Nazi’s were about to do was unthinkable. It also smacked in the face of modern ideas (even more pronounced today, but already around back then) that human beings were morally evolving or that there was really no such thing as evil.  Well, right now, I feel that I have gone back through time to warn you. No, I didn’t hitch hike a ride with Doc Brown and Marty McFly on their Delorean time machine. But I do see the beginnings of a new holocaust on the horizon, because again, history repeats itself.

 

While you listen to accusations of Jewish propaganda, as the “only source for the so-called holocaust,” please keep in mind that the phrase, “Jewish propaganda” was already used by the Nazi’s once upon a time, to turn the Germans against the Jews in the first place. On one hand, the Jews were a conspiracy of greedy capitalists who wanted to take over the world. On the other hand (for those with opposite concerns) the Jews were a conspiracy of Communists who wanted to take over the world. You see, those who believe in conspiracies never need to worry about contradicting themselves and never need to make a whole lot of sense and never need to back up their claims with documentation. After all, if the facts were that obvious, it wouldn’t be much of a conspiracy, right? Anti-Semitism is often viewed as a mystery. One of the few emotions shared by Extreme Right and Extreme Leftist fanatics, is a hatred of Jews.

 


 

On the other hand, I am Jewish. I too, may be accused of bias. I suppose there is some bias. We all have a little. I was raised Jewish and I would be lying if I didn’t confess the obvious, that there is much emotion associated with what I am writing. On the other hand, even though I was born into a Jewish home, I converted to Christianity during my second year of college. I will not go into the details right now. There is another series on Town Hall where I share my testimony and it has little to do with this present article. I mention it here briefly for only one reason: As a Jewish-Christian, I have often found myself (needless to say) at odds with fellow Jews. Theologically, I have been very critical of Judaism, especially regarding the obvious subject of Jesus. To claim Jesus as the Messiah is to disagree with Judaism on fundamental core beliefs. My point right now?  I have been willing to criticize Jews. Whether my criticism is valid or invalid, it does demonstrate a significant degree of objectivity. Please know that this author certainly is not one who defends all Jews right or wrong.

 

The situation is different with the nation of Israel. Here, I am on the side of Zionists (those who believe the Jews are entitled to a national homeland and who also believe Israel is, and always has been, their national homeland). My brother (an orthodox Jew) and I, get into frequent, spirited debates about Jesus, but we are on exactly the same page when the subject changes to Israel.

 

And yet, even here, I am in disagreement with many other Jews, specifically liberals. Liberal Jews in America and Liberal Jews in Israel (interestingly enough), tend to take the side of the Palestinians. Jews have often been their own worst enemy.

 

One more introductory disclaimer, and this one has to do with the relationship between Jews and Evangelical Christians.  A number of years ago, I spoke at Bethel Seminary in San Diego.  The subject was not Judaism, but rather, a defense for the entire Bible, Old and New Testament. Generally, such talks are followed by long Q and A times.  One of the seminarians raised his hand with an interesting question.  He had taken many classes about the End Times, the fulfillment of Bible prophecy and the second coming of Christ. Although there is a wide range of viewpoint amongst Christians, several of the popular teachings associate Jesus’ return with the nation of Israel. They insist that the Jewish return to the Promised Land in the Twentieth Century is a fulfillment of ancient scriptural predictions and they believe a future battle (the Battle of Armageddon) will climax in Christ’s rescuing of Israel from her enemies and ruling as king of the world, with Israel as his headquarters.

 

Anyway, let me share the seminarian’s question: “As a Christian, I feel obligated to take Israel’s side because of Bible prophecy, but when I follow the news I become concerned about Israeli abuses toward the persecuted Palestinians. What should I do about this?”

 

I appreciated the question and I offered a careful response:  “I believe in Bible prophecy but I do not believe prophecy should be the reason for Christians to side with Israel. Let me offer you a better reason, a human rights reason.  If we could correct the historical revision going on today, you would find yourself siding with Israel, regardless of Bible prophecy.”

 

And now, I can imagine, you the reader, thinking the following:

 

“OK, Bob. You have made your disclaimers. We have read your introduction. Just give us this true-false test about the Jews and Palestinians already.”

 

The test will begin in tomorrow’s blog. (Always leave them wanting more.)

 The Truth About Israel and Palestine: Part Two


Bibliography

 


1) The Complete Idiot’s Guide To Middle East

Conflict by Mitchell G. Bard, Ph.D

2) Philistine, by Ramon Bennett.


Also:

Politically Correct Quiz

Jihad Drill

How a Reformed Jew Became an Evangelical Christian Part One

How a Reformed Jew Became an Evangelical Christian Part Two

How A Reformed Jew Became an Evangelical Christian Part Three

How a Reformed Jew Became an Evangelical Christian Part Four

How a Reformed Jew Became an Evangelical Christian Part Five

The Bob Siegel Show can be heard every Sunday from 3:00 to 4:00 PM on KCBQ 1170 on the dial or KCBQ.com to listen live over the Internet.

Call in toll free number if you want to join in the program with questions or comments:

1-888-344-1170

Bob’s website is: www.bobsiegel.net

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | TrackbacksTrackbacks (4) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive