Posted by
Bob Siegel on Thursday, June 21, 2007 11:53:08 AM
There’s a tired old phrase that we hear today on media
debates, both radio and television “Just answer the question yes or no!”
OK, Let’s just get
this stupid thing settled once and for
all.
Basic debating rules 101:
On one hand I get frustrated when people avoid answering
direct questions. And yes, people do that all the time. They talk in circles,
hoping it will look like they answered the question when they really didn’t.
QUESTION: “Since many
Muslim clerics claim that Americans must convert to Islam or die,can you tell
me why they aren’t a real danger?”
ANSWER: “You wanna
talk about terrorists? How about George
Bush?”
Such a fudging, cowardly, political response does need to be
challenged.
On the other hand. there is only one fair way to ask and
answer yes and no questions, especially when the question is designed as an
obvious trap.
When I find myself on the receiving end of such inquiry, I
often respond, “I will answer yes or no only if I can explain my answer.”
In other words, “I will answer your question but in my own
words, not words you are attempting to put in my mouth. If after I say yes or no, you’re going
to cut me off with a smug victorious grin as if you just accomplished a
knockout at a prize fight, then all you’re doing is making a fool out of
yourself.”
Allow me to offer an example that makes the obvious,
obvious:
“Did you ever drive over the speed limit?”
“Well …I…”
“Yes or no! Did you ever drive over the speed limit?’
“Yes but…”
“Ha! No more
questions, Your Honor.”
“Wait! The answer is,Yes,
because I drive an ambulance.”
Note: The
Bob Siegel Show can be heard every Sunday from 3:00 to 4:00 PM on KCBQ 1170 on the dial or KCBQ.com to
listen live over the internet.
Call in toll free
number if you want to join in the program with questions or comments:
1-888-344-1170
Bob’s website is: www.bobsiegel.net